Standardised Speed Distributions - Turning Radii

Multimodal’s latest technical blog focuses on the use of speed distributions for different turning radii in microsimulation models. This follows on from the previous Dynamic Assignment and Speed Distributions topics

As with all of our technical posts, we acknowledge that these are not ‘set-in-stone’ methodologies and other techniques and processes may exist. However, we want to share our current processes to encourage feedback and improvement, as well as providing some guidance for those looking for a starting point on specific modelling methodologies.

This post focuses on the need to consider appropriate reduced speed areas for turns and then their associated speeds when developing microsimulation models.

Transport for London’s (TfL) Modelling Guidelines suggest that speed distributions used for turns should be dependent on the turning radii (see figure below).

Whilst the DfT and TfL free flow speed distributions can be utilised, we have reviewed other guidance to understand if there are other means of calculated more appropriate speeds for turning radii.

Our research led us to two main sources – Design Manual for Roads and Bridges (DMRB) and the Chartered Institute of Highways & Transportation’s (CIHT) Manual for Streets 2. From these documents, we followed two main steps.

 

Step 1 - Minimum Corner Radii identified from DMRB

TD42/95 from the DMRB suggests that the following radii should be a minimum for large goods vehicles for turning manoeuvres at junctions. We based our calculations on a large goods vehicle as this would provide a worst case for the road network modelled.

002b - Corner Radii.JPG

From these figures, we were able to determine that for different junction types, the highest braking / lowest speed distributions would be required for radii between 6m and 20m.

 

Step 2 - Calculate Design Speeds for Minimum Corner Radii

From Chapter 8.3 of Manual for Streets 2, design speeds were determined for the minimum corner radii derived from TD42/95.

Therefore, applying the V²/R value of 56 to the minimum corner radii from TD42/95, the following design speeds have been determined

To fit in with the Multimodal Standard VISSIM Template, corner desired speed distributions were split into three categories - Low Braking, Medium Braking and High Braking.

As a result, the following split of the results above have been chosen.

These speed distributions formed the basis of the turning radii speeds included within the VISSIM model and allowed individual turns measured (e.g. from OS Mapping in DWG format) to be assigned to an appropriate speed profile.

 

Final Comments

The use of the DMRB and Manual for Streets 2 Guidance has allowed Multimodal to develop an evidenced methodology in determining appropriate speed distributions for the associated turning radii.

It is acknowledged that this is not the only methodology available for identifying suitable speeds, but we feel it does provide a useful starting point in developing a base model for calibration and validation.

As with other modelling elements, the use of more local, site-specific data should always take president, if this data is available and able to be analysed appropriately.